What Non-Prime Cardholders Want From a Co-Brand Card

They found your brand. They booked with you. They took the risk of applying for your credit card. Then you declined them.

Rolando De Gracia, Chief Commercial Officer of Concora Credit, calls that one of the biggest missed opportunities in co-brand cards today. “You did all the heavy lifting,” he says, and then the customer walks away with nothing.

The numbers are hard to ignore. About 70 million Americans have FICO scores below 660, the Federal Reserve’s line for non-prime, and together they hold roughly $5 trillion in purchasing power. “There is this entire population in the US that has the GDP of Germany,” Rolando notes. Yet some brands launch cards in Canada or Europe before serving these customers at home.

In today’s K-shaped economy, prime issuers compete for super-prime spenders with premium cards. Meanwhile, middle- and lower-market consumers keep flying, staying and shopping with the same brands, and many are shut out of the loyalty benefits that come with a co-brand card.

What do these consumers want? Approval without a hit to their credit score, a guaranteed credit limit, and fees stated plainly up front. Rewards matter too, but many have been declined so often that they assume rewards aren’t meant for them. Their goals may be different from premium cardholders, but they are equally valid.

Concora’s answer is a “second look” card that sits in the decline waterfall. It earns the same loyalty currency, and when a cardholder’s credit improves, they can graduate back to the prime issuer. Rolando explains why secured cards and debit products, which require new accounts and moving money around, create more friction than a clear annual fee.

Rolando brings more than 20 years of credit card leadership from Household Finance, GE Capital and Alliance Data. He holds a BS from the University of Maryland and an MBA from Wharton.

Watch the full conversation below.

Time Stamps for the Time Starved

1:18 – Getting to know Rolando De Gracia
4:51 – The Impact of the K-shaped Economy on Consumer Credit
10:05 – Defining the market opportunity for second look credit
11:40 – Defining terms: Subprime, Non-Prime, Less than Perfect
13:33 – What is Second Look Approval?
17:43 – 5 Things that Matter to Consumers
21:48 – The Role of Rewards in Second Look Credit
26:23 – Structuring a Second Look Program
28:20 – Important Takeaways - What You Need to Know
34:37 – Serving the Silent Majority in Consumer Credit